Fromm vs TOTW

[imthemonkey]

I am really curious to see what you guys think is a better food. Would you rather feed the 25% / 15% TOTW formulas or feed Fromm's 4 star?

Fromm's Duck and Sweet Potato is 24/15 and their Salmon formula is 25/16.

Taking protein and quality into account, and if your dog isnt allergic to grains, which would you choose?

[cavalcadegsmd]

I haven't read the label of either product but, I would go with Fromm. I say this because it to me is smaller company and more trust worthy. TOTW is a Diamond product and they had a lethal problem some years back and have some really junky formulas- these combined makes me avoid their products. I know this didn't address you "protein and quality" criteria, but there's not that much difference between them in my opinion.

[Tzubabies]

I'm actually feeding Fromm 4star Duck & Sweet Potato right now! As the poster above me mentioned, I trust the company much more. In TOTW I don't like the "ocean fish meal" because it is a mystery ingredient. I personally like the ingredients in Fromm better. I think the main appeal of TOTW is it's price. If it cost more, then I think less people would feed it.

[PDXdogmom]

I've never tried the TOTW formulas. First, I don't have a high trust factor with Diamond. Second, I don't like that they used "smoked" meats in their formulas. That is a carcinogen red flag to me. If my dog needed to eat grain-free, I would look for another brand over TOTW.

[Tzubabies]

I've never tried the TOTW formulas. First, I don't have a high trust factor with Diamond. Second, I don't like that they used "smoked" meats in their formulas. That is a carcinogen red flag to me. If my dog needed to eat grain-free, I would look for another brand over TOTW.

I forgot about the smoked meats. It was a long time ago, but I fed one bag and just didn't feel comfortable with it.

[truthdog]

Fromm Gold is the best formula from Fromm. TOTW is trash.

[Porphyria]

I've been rotating the Fromm Four Star formulas for several months; my dog has done very well on it and he loves all of the flavors. I haven't fed TOTW because I'm not really comfortable with Diamond.

[MollyWoppy]

I ditto all the above. Fromm costs a bit more, but to me it's worth it. Fromm is one of two types of kibbles my cat will eat and I'm happy with that.

[cavalcadegsmd]

How do those of you who replied feel about Holistic Select and Earthborn? These are two that I would never consider because of the junky stuff they also make (ProPac and Prism.)

[DaViking]

I started the switch from the breeders Kirkland to Fromm 4 Star Surf & Turf today as an ALS. I considered Fromm's Puppy Gold too but wanted to try out the Four Star series first.